• Banner 1
  • Banner 2
  • Banner 3

Eddie & Sam's NY Pizza: Authentic New York Style Pizza in Downtown Tampa

At Eddie & Sam's NY Pizza, the spirit of authentic New York pizza comes to life in the heart of Tampa. Known for its delightful, crispy crust and rich, homemade tomato sauce, this establishment offers a mouthwatering selection of pizzas alongside fresh salads and delicious desserts. With the convenience of quick self-service kiosks and ample outdoor seating, it caters to pizza lovers of all ages. Patrons rave about the generous portions and fresh toppings, emphasizing that every slice transports them back to the bustling streets of NYC. Pop in to enjoy the casual, inviting ambiance while savoring an elite pizza experience!

Eddie & Sam's NY Pizza at a glance

  • Address 203 E Twiggs St Tampa, FL 33602 United States
  • Phone (813) 229-8500
  • Restaurant type Pizza restaurant .
  • Popular for Popular for lunch , Popular for dinner , Good for solo dining .

Photos & Gallery

Eddie & Sam's NY Pizza: Reviews & Ratings

Honest foodie
4

Let me start with I live in NY my entire life and love pizza. This is the best pizza I have had in Florida period and I have tried a good amount of establishments. The service is great. Pizza was good, was it Brooklyn,NY pizza?No. But it was a good pie. The place was packed as I was there to walk to the hockey game.

Ides of March B
4

Is it a good pizza? Yes. Is it authentic NY pizza? Not really, but it certainly has some of the elements of NY pizza. NY/NJ is very hard to duplicate outside of those states...they say it's the water....it is a very good option for pizza in the area

Zuly Rodriguez
5

Being a NYer hard to find good pizza here in florida. For me it all about the sauce and then the dough. I hate greasy pizza. Even back in NY. I only tried the buffalo chicken pizza and it was pretty good. The crust what sold me to try again. It was an amazing crust. They pizza was not bad. It was a little salty for me but overall not bad. Definitely what to try just plain cheese or pepperoni to see if they have real NY pizza. It is tampa so good luck finding a parking spot being this is located right on the corner of a VERY busy area.

Jennifer Serrano
5

One of the best pizza spots in Tampa for some good NY Pizza! The giant slices are actually truly giant sized. Some places claim to have giant pizza slices and they’ll look like some little Caesar’s slices I had a cheese slice and cut my white pizza in half to share with my hubby. Hit the spot, so good. This place has always been consistent and delicious!

Marty
4

4 Stars, Let me start by saying this pizza was good, above average overall, but not true NY style. I have had my share of pizza as a native New Yorker and as a certified pizza judge over the years. The crust/dough of this pizza pie was more of a cracker like consistency, less chew than like NY style crust, lackes in flavor, missing the yeast taste, and overall bland dough. Again it was not bad pizza but its not NY pie. Toppings are of decent quality, good ratio of toppings, fantastic selection of slices ready to go. Great service, decent seating areas. Parking.... i know its not the restaurants fault but good luck on that, when you do its 14$ at the lots, the real NY experience. Grandma pizza was excellent, great flavors and overall excellent experience. Tiramisu was ok. Instagram/TikTok @foodieadventuresusa

Jarrod Cleveland
5

It's all true. The legend about the water. It does make the crust THAT good. And listen to the guy that recommended the lasagna pizza. Fantastic, the people are nice. Go here.

Kimberly Mcavoy
5

Tampa Bay Food Tours is always on the hunt for a great bite in Downtown Tampa — and if you’re looking for the real deal New York slice, Eddie & Sam’s delivers. They’ve been slinging pizza here for years. Family-owned and famously importing their water straight from New York to get that authentic crust, this is the spot where you can grab your favorite slice without committing to a whole pie… because is it even NY pizza if you can’t order it by the slice? It’s immensely popular — expect a lively scene with self-service kiosks and multiple counter stations keeping the lines moving. Perfect for a quick lunch or a late-night stop, it’s about as close as you’ll get to a true NYC pizzeria experience right here in Tampa.

Humanity wins ! (Humanity wins)
5

Huge sliced flavorful hot plenty of Pizzas...like 20 different sliced ready to serve and eat. And the have a 26" pie... ALL MADE WITH NY WATER ! AWESOMENESS DOWNTOWN TAMPA.

Location

  • Eddie & Sam's NY Pizza
    Eddie & Sam's NY Pizza
    203 E Twiggs St Tampa, FL 33602 United States Hotline: (813) 229-8500

If you're in downtown Tampa and craving a taste of New York, look no further than Eddie & Sam's NY Pizza. This beloved eatery has established itself as a go-to destination for pizza aficionados, offering a slice of authentic New York-style pizza right in the heart of Florida.

Located at 203 E Twiggs St, Tampa, FL, Eddie & Sam's combines the best of classic pizza traditions with a casual atmosphere that welcomes everyone—from families to groups of friends. Noted for its no-fuss ordering system, you can quickly place your order at the self-service kiosks, allowing you to indulge in your pizza without a long wait.

  • Wide Variety: The menu features everything from classic cheese pizzas to unique options like BBQ Chicken, ensuring there’s something for everyone. A must-try is their 14" Cheese Pizza, which serves up to 3 people and is perfectly topped with high-quality whole milk mozzarella. If you're hosting a gathering, their 28" Party Size can cater to larger groups.
  • Fresh Ingredients: Customers rave about the freshness of the toppings and the sauce, which is touted to be "to die for." Many patrons, like Matt G., describe the pizza as some of the best in Florida—providing a standout pizza experience that rivals even the most popular spots in New York City.
  • Convenience: With amenities such as outdoor seating, catering options, and the allowance of dogs, Eddie & Sam’s is the perfect eatery for any occasion. They accept multiple payment methods, including Apple Pay and Android Pay, making your dining experience even smoother.

The ambiance strikes a perfect balance between casual and classy, making it an ideal setting for lunch or dinner. It's also a great place for kids and groups—just the right mix of flavors and fun. Plus, for those who like to grab a meal on the go, takeout and delivery are readily available.

Reviewers like Wendy F. mention the significance of Eddie & Sam's unique approach, including the use of New York water to create that quintessential crust—an element that many believe adds to the pizza’s authenticity. With consistently positive feedback, including quick service and a welcoming environment, it's no surprise that this pizzeria has become a staple in the community.

So, if you find yourself wandering through downtown Tampa and in need of a delightful meal, make sure to swing by Eddie & Sam's NY Pizza. Whether you're indulging in a classic cheese slice or exploring their varied menu of appetizers and pizzas, your taste buds are in for a real treat.

Business Information

  • Accessibility
    • Has wheelchair-accessible car park
    • Has wheelchair-accessible entrance
    • Has wheelchair-accessible seating
    • Has wheelchair-accessible toilet
  • Service options
    • Has outdoor seating
    • Has no-contact delivery
    • Offers delivery
    • On-site services available
    • Offers takeaway
    • Serves dine-in
  • Payments
    • Accepts credit cards
    • Accepts debit cards
    • Accepts NFC mobile payments
    • Credit cards